Common Types of Failure in Strength of Materials
Introduction to the types of failure in the strength of materials
In the context of the strength of materials (also known as mechanics of materials or solid mechanics), failure refers to the inability of a material or structural element to perform its desired function due to deformation, cracking, or other forms of material breakdown under various types of loads. There are several key types of failure modes:
Tensile Failure:
Tensile failure occurs when a material is subjected to a stretching force that causes it to break or fracture. This type of failure is characterized by elongation and eventual separation of the material under stress.
Cause: Tensile failure happens when materials are subjected to a tensile force that exceeds their ultimate tensile strength. This is the maximum stress a material can withstand before it starts to break down. In tensile testing, materials are pulled apart, and failure occurs once the material can no longer endure the stretching force.
Manifestations: In a standard tensile test, one can observe the formation of a “neck” in ductile materials as they are pulled apart. The material locally reduces in cross-section at the neck until it eventually breaks. In brittle materials, no necking is observed, and the material may break suddenly without significant deformation.
Consequences: Structural elements under tension fail by stretching and ultimately rupturing. In ductile materials, tensile failure can be preceded by significant elongation, while in brittle materials, the failure can occur suddenly without warning. This type of failure is critical in load-bearing structures such as bridges, cables, or pressure vessels under tensile stress.
Compressive Failure:
Compressive failure occurs when materials are subjected to compressive forces and are unable to bear the load, causing them to deform or collapse. Materials under compression may exhibit different failure modes depending on their ductility or brittleness.
Cause: When materials are subjected to forces that compress them, they may undergo various forms of compressive failure. In ductile materials, failure might involve buckling or barreling, while in brittle materials, compression can lead to cracking, crushing, or shattering. The type of compressive failure depends on the material’s properties and how it responds to axial stress.
Manifestations: Ductile materials under compression may exhibit “barreling” behavior due to the Poisson effect, where the material expands laterally as it compresses. Brittle materials, on the other hand, may crack or shatter upon reaching their compressive limit. Structural elements like columns or walls under compression can also experience buckling if the material or design cannot support the applied load.
Consequences: Compressive failure is critical in components like columns, pillars, or structural supports where a failure can lead to the collapse of the entire structure. The deformation or collapse of these components can result in a loss of structural integrity, posing safety risks in buildings, bridges, and pressure vessels.
Shear Failure:
Shear failure happens when forces cause one part of a material to slide relative to the adjacent part, creating a shear force that leads to the separation of materials. This failure mode is common in beams, joints, or bolted connections subjected to heavy loads.
Cause: Shear failure is caused by forces that act parallel to the material’s surface, causing it to slip or slide over adjacent surfaces. When the ultimate shear strength of the material is surpassed, failure occurs.
Manifestations: Shear failure can be observed in structural joints or cross-sections of beams, particularly in areas where rivets or bolts are used to join materials. Under heavy loads, the material may fail along the shear plane, causing the connected parts to separate.
Consequences: Structural joints or connections are prone to shear failure, which can lead to the detachment of critical components. In large structures, shear failure can result in catastrophic collapses if essential load-bearing elements fail to support the shear forces.
Buckling:
Buckling is a form of failure that occurs when slender structural elements, such as columns or beams, are subjected to compressive loads and deform laterally. This failure mode is especially dangerous because it can occur suddenly and without warning.
Cause: Buckling occurs when a structural member is subjected to compressive forces that exceed its critical buckling load. Factors like boundary conditions, geometric imperfections, and slenderness ratios play a significant role in determining a member’s susceptibility to buckling.
Manifestations: Buckling is often observed in slender columns or plates under compressive loads, where the member deforms laterally and loses its load-bearing capacity. The member may bend, twist, or buckle in a way that compromises its structural integrity.
Consequences: Buckling leads to instability in structural elements, which can cause sudden collapses. Buckling is a critical concern in tall structures, thin-walled pressure vessels, or bridge supports, where a loss of stability can lead to catastrophic failure.
Fatigue Failure:
Fatigue failure occurs when a material is subjected to repeated or fluctuating loads over time, even if the loads are below the material’s yield strength. Tiny cracks form and grow over multiple cycles, ultimately leading to the material’s fracture.
Cause: Fatigue failure is caused by fluctuating or cyclic loads applied to a material over time. These repetitive stresses, even if they are below the material’s yield strength, can cause micro-cracks to form and grow, weakening the material with each cycle until it eventually ruptures.
Manifestations: Fatigue failure is characterized by the appearance of “beach marks” at the fracture site, which show the progression of crack growth over many load cycles. The fracture surface may exhibit distinct regions where cracks initiated, propagated, and ultimately caused the final rupture.
Consequences: Fatigue failure is especially dangerous because it can occur even in materials that are seemingly operating within safe stress limits. Components subjected to cyclic loading, such as aircraft parts, machinery, and bridges, are at risk of fatigue failure if cracks are not detected and repaired in time.
Brittle Failure:
Brittle failure is the sudden and catastrophic breaking of a material without significant plastic deformation. It occurs with little warning and is often associated with materials like glass, ceramics, and some metals under certain conditions.
Cause: Brittle failure occurs when materials, such as high-carbon steels, ceramics, or glass, are subjected to stresses that exceed their brittle strength. In brittle materials, fracture occurs without significant warning or deformation, usually at low temperatures or under fast-loading conditions.
Manifestations: Brittle failure is characterized by the sudden breakage of the material, which often occurs along crystalline planes. The fracture surface may appear shiny or glassy, and the material shows no signs of elongation or plastic deformation before breaking.
Consequences: Brittle failure is highly dangerous because it occurs suddenly and without significant deformation, making it difficult to predict. This type of failure can lead to catastrophic consequences in safety-critical applications such as pressure vessels, pipelines, or structural supports.
Ductile Failure:
Ductile failure is preceded by significant plastic deformation, allowing the material to absorb more energy before breaking. It is often observed in materials subjected to tensile stresses and is preferred over brittle failure due to the warning signs it provides.
Cause: Ductile failure occurs when a material is subjected to tensile forces beyond its yield strength, leading to significant plastic deformation before breaking. Ductile materials, such as low-carbon steels and some alloys, are able to stretch and absorb energy before rupture.
Manifestations: Ductile failure is characterized by “necking,” where the material thins in one location as it approaches failure. The material may also exhibit plastic elongation, allowing for significant deformation before the final fracture.
Consequences: Ductile failure is often preferable because it provides clear warning signs before total rupture, such as plastic deformation and necking. This allows engineers to take preventive measures before the material completely fails, reducing the risk of sudden, catastrophic failures in critical applications.
Creep:
Creep refers to the slow, time-dependent deformation of a material under a constant load or stress, particularly when exposed to high temperatures. It is a critical concern in applications involving high-temperature environments, such as power plants, engines, and turbines, where components are subjected to long-term stress.
Cause: Creep occurs when materials are exposed to a constant load or stress, particularly at elevated temperatures. Over time, the material undergoes gradual deformation, slowly elongating or warping under the load. The rate of creep increases with both temperature and stress levels.
Manifestations: Over time, materials, especially metals used in high-temperature applications, may slowly elongate or deform. Creep can lead to visible sagging, thinning, or distortion in structural components. In severe cases, continued creep can lead to “creep rupture,” where the material eventually fails and fractures.
Consequences: Creep is particularly critical in high-temperature applications like turbines, engines, and boilers, where the structural integrity of components is vital for proper functioning. Components that undergo creep can deform or lose functionality, potentially leading to catastrophic failure if they are not replaced in time.
Thermal Failure:
Thermal failure occurs when materials are subjected to sudden or extreme temperature changes, leading to thermal stress and eventual cracking or warping. This type of failure is common in environments where materials are exposed to fluctuating temperatures, such as in engines, turbines, or industrial machinery.
Cause: Rapid temperature changes can cause materials to expand or contract, leading to thermal stress. When temperature fluctuations occur too quickly, the material does not have time to adjust, resulting in cracks or warping. Constrained thermal expansion, where parts of the material are restricted from expanding uniformly, can also lead to stress and failure.
Manifestations: Thermal failure often results in visible cracking or warping of materials. This can occur due to rapid temperature changes, such as heating or cooling in a short period, or stress from constrained thermal expansion.
Consequences: In structures or components exposed to high-temperature fluctuations, thermal failure can lead to significant damage. Cracks may weaken the material, while warping can cause components to lose their proper alignment or functionality. Thermal failure is especially problematic in high-temperature environments, such as industrial furnaces, engines, or turbines.
Corrosion:
Corrosion refers to the chemical or electrochemical degradation of materials, particularly metals, when exposed to corrosive environments. It is not a mechanical failure mode in itself but can significantly weaken materials over time, making them more susceptible to mechanical failure under stress.
Cause: Corrosion occurs when materials, especially metals, react with their environment, such as exposure to moisture, chemicals, or oxygen. Common forms of corrosion include oxidation (rusting), galvanic corrosion (caused by dissimilar metals in contact), and stress-corrosion cracking (caused by the combined effects of stress and corrosive environments).
Manifestations: Corrosion can manifest as pitting, surface degradation, or stress-corrosion cracking. The material’s surface may develop rust, or small pits may form, gradually reducing the material’s cross-sectional area. Stress-corrosion cracking can also develop in materials subjected to both stress and corrosive environments.
Consequences: Corrosion leads to the gradual weakening of the material, reducing its load-bearing capacity and mechanical properties. If left unchecked, corrosion can lead to the failure of critical components, such as pipes, pressure vessels, or structural supports, posing safety risks in industrial settings.
Hydrogen Embrittlement:
Hydrogen embrittlement is a phenomenon in which metals, particularly high-strength steels, become brittle and prone to fracture after absorbing hydrogen. This type of failure is particularly concerning in critical applications where metal components are exposed to hydrogen environments, such as in the aerospace, oil and gas, and chemical processing industries.
Cause: Hydrogen embrittlement occurs when metals absorb hydrogen, typically from their environment, such as during electroplating, exposure to hydrogen gas, or during corrosion processes. The absorbed hydrogen atoms diffuse into the metal’s structure, making it brittle and reducing its ability to deform plastically.
Manifestations: Metals affected by hydrogen embrittlement become brittle and show decreased ductility. This can lead to sudden, premature failure without significant warning. Cracks can propagate through the material, often leading to catastrophic failure.
Consequences: Hydrogen embrittlement is particularly problematic in high-strength steels used in critical applications such as pipelines, aircraft components, and industrial machinery. The sudden, brittle fracture can result in significant damage, posing safety risks and potentially leading to costly repairs or replacements.
Stress Corrosion Cracking:
Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) is a dangerous failure mode that occurs when tensile stress and a corrosive environment combine to cause cracking in materials. SCC can occur even when the applied stresses are well below the material’s yield strength, making it particularly insidious.
Cause: Stress corrosion cracking occurs when a material is subjected to a combination of tensile stress and exposure to a corrosive environment. The presence of specific corrosive substances, such as chlorides or sulfides, can initiate cracking, which propagates under the influence of tensile stress. SCC is common in metals such as stainless steel, aluminum, and certain alloys.
Manifestations: Stress corrosion cracking typically manifests as small cracks that develop in the presence of both stress and corrosive agents. These cracks grow over time and can lead to sudden fracture without significant prior warning. The fracture surface may display evidence of stress and corrosion working in tandem to weaken the material.
Consequences: Components affected by stress corrosion cracking can fail suddenly, even if the applied loads are well below the material’s yield strength. SCC is particularly concerning in critical applications such as chemical processing equipment, pipelines, and pressure vessels, where failure can lead to catastrophic consequences, including leaks, explosions, or structural collapse.
Impact Failure:
- Caused by a sudden force or blow. The failure can be either ductile or brittle, depending on the rate of load application and material properties.
In the field of strength of materials, it’s essential to understand these failure modes and their underlying causes. Proper knowledge ensures the safe and efficient design of structures and machinery, ensuring longevity and reliability.
Need a reliable partner?
FAQ: Understanding Types of Failure in the Strength of Materials
What are the common types of material failure in pressure vessels?
Material failure in pressure vessels typically occurs due to factors like stress corrosion cracking, fatigue, and brittle fracture. Stress corrosion cracking happens when a material corrodes under tensile stress, particularly in harsh chemical environments. Fatigue failure is caused by repeated stress cycles, leading to cracks and eventual fracture. Brittle fracture, on the other hand, occurs suddenly and without much deformation, often at low temperatures or under high strain rates.
How does thermal stress impact the strength of materials in pressure vessels?
Thermal stress arises from temperature gradients within the material of a pressure vessel. When different parts of the vessel expand or contract at different rates due to temperature changes, it creates internal stresses. This can lead to thermal fatigue, where repeated heating and cooling cycles weaken the material. In extreme cases, it can cause cracking or even catastrophic failure, especially if the material is not designed to withstand such thermal stresses.
Can the shape and design of a pressure vessel affect its failure modes?
Yes, the shape and design of a pressure vessel significantly influence its failure modes. For instance, sharp corners or abrupt changes in thickness can create stress concentrations, making these areas more prone to crack initiation and propagation. Cylindrical vessels with hemispherical ends are often used to minimize these stress concentrations. Additionally, the placement of nozzles, supports, and other attachments must be carefully designed to avoid weak points.
What role does material selection play in preventing failure in pressure vessels?
Material selection is crucial in preventing failure in pressure vessels. The material must be able to withstand the internal pressure, corrosive substances (if any), and temperature ranges it will be exposed to. Factors like tensile strength, corrosion resistance, ductility, and fracture toughness are considered. For instance, stainless steel is often chosen for its corrosion resistance, while carbon steel might be preferred for its strength and cost-effectiveness.
How does manufacturing quality affect the strength and failure of pressure vessels?
Manufacturing quality plays a pivotal role in the strength and longevity of pressure vessels. Flaws during the manufacturing process, such as improper welding, inadequate heat treatment, or poor quality control, can introduce weaknesses in the vessel. These flaws might lead to premature failure under operational stresses. Ensuring high manufacturing standards, such as adhering to ASME codes and conducting rigorous testing, is essential for the reliability and safety of pressure vessels.
Related Blog Post
- What are the 3 major hazards related to pressure vessels?
- What are the 6 case histories of pressure vessel failures?
- What is the external pressure failure of pressure vessels?
- What are the types of failure in the strength of materials?
- What are the different types of pressure vessel stress?
- What are the failure modes of pressure transducers?
- What are the factors affecting pressure vessels?
- What are the common failure modes of valves?
- What are the different types of failure safety
- What are the failure modes of ships?
- What is a type 4 pressure vessel?
- What are the 2 types of mechanical failure?
Solutions
In the realm of industrial solutions, Red River emerges as a pioneer, offering a diverse range of custom-engineered products and facilities. Among our specialties is the design and production of Custom/OEM Pressure Vessels, meticulously crafted to meet individual client requirements, ensuring performance under various pressure conditions. Our expertise extends to the domain of prefabrication, where Red River leads with distinction.
The company excels in creating prefabricated facilities, modules, and packages, reinforcing its stance as a forerunner in innovation and quality. This proficiency is further mirrored in their Modular Skids offering, where they provide an array of Modular Fabricated Skid Packages and Packaged equipment. Each piece is tailored to client specifications, underlining their commitment to delivering precision and excellence in every project they undertake.
